I assume that both motors are driving the common shaft at the same time. That is, you do noy have a main and standby motor situation.
If this is the case, you would be better off in the long run to keep the motors matched by replacing both of them with your new motor of choice. The information provided by contributors Nordell and Mulani highlight the potential dangers of a mismatch.
10668 Newbury Ave., N.W.,
Uniontown, Ohio 44685 USA
Tel: 001 330 265 5881
FAX: 001 330 494 1704